We may receive compensation from the providers of the services and products featured on this website. This impacts the offers’ positioning, rating & scoring. Advertising Disclosure

Raw vs. Cooked: The Ultimate Dog Diet Showdown

Raw vs. Cooked Which Diet is Best for Your Dog?

The Great Dog Diet Debate Begins

Every dog owner wants the best for their furry friend, especially when it comes to their diet. The debate between raw and cooked diets has been a hot topic among pet enthusiasts and experts alike. But which is truly the best for your dog? Let’s embark on a journey to uncover the truth, backed by science, expert opinions, and the values of top pet food brands.

The Raw Truth: Benefits and Concerns of a Raw Diet

Raw diets, often referred to as BARF (Biologically Appropriate Raw Food), have gained popularity in recent years. Advocates believe it’s the most natural way to feed dogs, mimicking their ancestral diet.

Pros of a Raw Diet:

  • Natural Nutrients: Raw foods retain their natural nutrients, which might get lost during the cooking process. This ensures your dog gets vitamins and minerals in their most natural form.
  • Dental Health: Chewing raw bones can help in reducing tartar buildup, promoting better dental health.
  • Improved Digestion: Many dog owners report better digestion and fewer stools when their pets are on a raw diet.

Cons of a Raw Diet:

  • Safety Concerns: Raw diets can be a breeding ground for bacteria if not handled and stored properly. This can pose health risks to both pets and humans.
  • Nutritional Imbalance: Without proper knowledge, it’s easy to provide an imbalanced diet, which can lead to nutritional deficiencies or excesses.
  • Cost: High-quality raw diets can be more expensive than their cooked counterparts.

Brands like Spot & Tango and We Feed Raw specialize in providing balanced raw diets, ensuring your dog gets all the necessary nutrients. Their commitment to quality and transparency aligns with the values of pet lovers who prioritize humane treatment of animals and product quality.

Cooked to Perfection: Advantages and Drawbacks of Cooked Diets

Cooked diets have been the traditional choice for many dog owners. These diets are prepared by cooking the ingredients, ensuring safety and palatability.

Pros of a Cooked Diet:

  • Safety: Cooking eliminates harmful pathogens, making the food safer for consumption.
  • Palatability: Some dogs prefer the taste and texture of cooked food over raw.
  • Digestibility: Cooking breaks down fibers, making the food easier to digest for some dogs.

Cons of a Cooked Diet:

  • Loss of Nutrients: Cooking can lead to the loss of some essential nutrients, which might need to be supplemented.
  • Allergies: Some dogs might develop allergies or sensitivities to certain cooked foods.

Brands like NomNomNow and MyOllie offer high-quality cooked meals tailored to your dog’s needs. They prioritize transparency, ensuring pet owners are well-informed about the ingredients and cooking processes.

The Middle Ground: Dehydrated and Freeze-Dried Options

For those looking for a middle ground, dehydrated and freeze-dried foods offer the benefits of both raw and cooked diets. Brands like Open Farm and Sundays have harnessed the power of these methods to provide nutritious meals without compromising on safety.


  • Long Shelf Life: These foods have a longer shelf life compared to fresh raw or cooked meals.
  • Nutrient Retention: The dehydration and freeze-drying processes retain most of the nutrients.


  • Cost: These options can be pricier than traditional kibble.

Making the Right Choice: Factors to Consider

Choosing between raw and cooked diets boils down to your dog’s individual needs and your personal preferences. Here are some factors to consider:

  • Your Dog’s Health: Some dogs with specific health issues might benefit more from one diet over the other. Always consult with a veterinarian before making a switch.
  • Safety and Handling: If you’re concerned about handling raw food, a cooked or dehydrated option might be better.
  • Cost: Your budget will play a significant role in your decision. While some high-quality diets can be expensive, they often offer better value in the long run, as highlighted in our article on Choosing the Best Puppy Food.

The Science Behind the Diet: Nutritional Needs of Dogs

Every dog, regardless of breed or size, has specific nutritional needs. While the debate between raw and cooked diets continues, it’s essential to understand the science behind canine nutrition.


  • Proteins: Dogs require high-quality proteins for muscle development and repair. Both raw and cooked diets can provide this, but the source and quality of protein matter. For instance, raw diets often include muscle meat, organs, and bones, while cooked diets might use lean meats and supplement with essential amino acids.
  • Fats: Essential for energy and the absorption of certain vitamins. Fats also play a crucial role in brain development and maintaining healthy skin and coat. Whether you choose raw or cooked, ensure the diet provides a good balance of Omega-3 and Omega-6 fatty acids. Dive deeper into the benefits of Omega-3 in our article on Unlocking the Health Benefits of Omega-3 for Your Dog.
  • Carbohydrates: While dogs don’t necessarily need carbohydrates, they can be a good energy source. Cooked diets often include carbs like rice, potatoes, or oats, while raw diets might have limited carbs from fruits and vegetables.


  • Vitamins and Minerals: Essential for various bodily functions, from bone health to immune response. Both diets can provide these, but it’s crucial to ensure a balanced intake. For instance, raw diets might require supplementation to prevent deficiencies.
  • Water: Often overlooked, but vital. Raw diets naturally have a higher moisture content, while cooked diets, especially dry kibble, require your dog to drink more water.

Customizing the Diet: Every Dog is Unique

While general guidelines are helpful, every dog is unique. Factors like age, breed, activity level, and health conditions play a significant role in determining the best diet.

  • Puppies vs. Adults: Puppies have different nutritional needs compared to adult dogs. They require more protein and fat for growth. Whether you choose raw or cooked, ensure the diet meets these needs.
  • Active vs. Sedentary: Active dogs might require more calories, while sedentary dogs might need fewer to prevent obesity. Learn more about managing canine obesity through diet in our article on Canine Obesity: The Power of Diet for Prevention and Management.
  • Health Conditions: Dogs with specific health conditions might benefit from one diet over the other. For instance, dogs with pancreatitis might require a low-fat diet, while those with allergies might benefit from a limited ingredient diet.

The Brands Making a Difference

When choosing a diet, it’s essential to consider the brands behind the products. Brands like The Farmer’s Dog prioritize transparency and quality, ensuring pet owners are well-informed about the ingredients and sourcing processes. Their commitment to humane treatment of animals and sustainability aligns with the values of discerning pet lovers.

Beyond the Diet: Holistic Pet Care

Diet is just one aspect of pet care. Regular exercise, mental stimulation, routine vet check-ups, and love and attention are equally important. While a balanced diet provides the foundation for good health, a holistic approach ensures your dog leads a happy and fulfilling life.

The Verdict: Raw or Cooked – Which Reigns Supreme?

The debate between raw and cooked diets for dogs is as diverse as the breeds themselves. While both diets have their merits, the best choice ultimately depends on your dog’s individual needs and your personal preferences.

Factors to Weigh In:

  • Safety First: If you’re leaning towards a raw diet, ensure you’re well-informed about safe handling and storage practices. Brands like Spot & Tango prioritize safety, providing guidelines for pet owners.
  • Nutritional Balance: Whether raw or cooked, the diet should be nutritionally balanced. Brands like NomNomNow offer tailored meal plans, ensuring your dog gets all the essential nutrients.
  • Cost and Convenience: While raw diets can offer a plethora of benefits, they might be more expensive and require more preparation time. On the other hand, high-quality cooked diets offer convenience without compromising on quality.
  • Listen to Your Dog: Sometimes, the best indicator is your dog. Monitor their health, energy levels, coat quality, and overall well-being after switching diets. If they thrive, you’ve found the right fit!

Expert Opinions Matter

While personal research is invaluable, consulting with a veterinarian or a canine nutritionist can provide insights tailored to your dog’s specific needs. They can offer guidance on transitioning diets, potential supplements, and address any health concerns.

A Note on Treats and Supplements

While the primary diet is crucial, don’t forget about treats and supplements. Ensure they align with the chosen diet and offer nutritional benefits. For instance, if you’re on a raw diet journey, consider treats that complement this choice, like freeze-dried liver or raw bones. Dive into the world of treats with our article on Choosing the Perfect Treats for Your Dog.

In the End, Love is the Key Ingredient

At ThePetPicks.com, we believe that love is the foundation of every choice we make for our furry friends. Our deep love for dogs drives us to scrutinize every product and service, ensuring you can trust our comparisons as much as your furry friend trusts you. Because, after all, they’re family.

Frequently Asked Questions: Unleashing the Truth

Why is there a debate between raw and cooked diets?

The debate stems from the desire to provide the best for our pets. While raw diets aim to mimic a dog’s natural diet, cooked diets prioritize safety and convenience. Both have their merits, and the choice often boils down to individual preferences and a dog’s specific needs.

Are there any risks associated with raw diets?

Yes, raw diets can pose risks if not handled and stored correctly. There’s a potential for bacterial contamination, which can affect both pets and humans. It’s essential to follow safe handling guidelines and ensure the diet is nutritionally balanced.

How do I transition my dog from a cooked diet to a raw diet (or vice versa)?

Transitioning should be gradual to prevent digestive upset. Start by mixing a small amount of the new diet with the current one, gradually increasing the new diet’s proportion over 7-10 days. Monitor your dog for any signs of digestive issues and consult with a veterinarian if needed.

Can I mix raw and cooked diets?

While it’s possible, it’s essential to ensure the combined diet is nutritionally balanced. Some experts advise against mixing due to different digestion rates, but if you choose to mix, consult with a canine nutritionist to ensure you’re meeting all nutritional requirements.

How do I know if a particular diet is right for my dog?

Monitor your dog’s health, energy levels, coat quality, and overall well-being. If they seem to thrive, have regular bowel movements, and show no signs of allergies or digestive issues, the diet is likely a good fit. However, always consult with a veterinarian for a professional opinion.

This guide aims to provide comprehensive information on raw vs. cooked diets for dogs. However, it’s not a substitute for professional veterinary advice. Always consult with a veterinarian or canine nutritionist for specific dietary recommendations for your pet.

Affiliate Disclosure

All of the Third Party Offers we make available through the website, are of Third-Party Providers we have a business engagement with.  This means that we receive consideration whenever one of our users decides to click on the Third Party Offers, or otherwise connect, sign up or purchase a service or product from such Third-Party Providers. 

The placement of certain Third Party Offer, as well as any rating or scoring we may assign, are affected by such consideration we receive from the Third-Party Providers, and might be further subject to our additional internal consideration and criteria, such as, statistics of users’ engagement with a certain Third -Party Provider, etc. 

 We make efforts to ensure the information on our website, including Third Party Offer’s terms, are up to date however, the Third-Party Offer’s terms can be changed at any time, subject to the Third-Party Provider’s sole discretion, and we have no control or any responsibility in this regard. We do not compare or review all service providers or products available in the market.

The Website Content, including any rating and scoring are provided by us “as-is”.